| | | Allegheny wins the coin toss, receives; DePauw defends south goal. |
| | | Marko Adams kickoff 65 yards to the ALL0, Jake Wilson return 24 yards to the ALL24 (Bren. Connelly), PENALTY ALL holding 10 yards to the ALL14, 1st and 10, ALL ball on ALL14. |
| All | 1-10 | at All14 | Tyler Balla rush for no gain to the ALL14 (Will Longthorne;Joel Kauth). |
| All | 2-10 | at All14 | Alex Victor rush for loss of 1 yard to the ALL13 (Kevin Kiyosaki). |
| All | 3-11 | at All13 | Logan Lee sacked for loss of 7 yards to the ALL6 (Nate Orrison). |
| All | 4-18 | at All06 | McLaughlin punt 32 yards to the ALL38, fair catch by Brooks Hepp. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 8 yards, TOP 02:14 |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at All38 | DEPAUW UNIVERSITY drive start at 12:46. |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at All38 | Jason Kirchhoff rush for no gain to the ALL38 (Matt Ledesma). |
| Dpu | 2-10 | at All38 | Matt Hunt pass complete to Jason Kirchhoff for 18 yards to the ALL20, 1ST DOWN DPU (Craye Nehler). |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at All20 | Jason Kirchhoff rush for 20 yards to the ALL0, 1ST DOWN DPU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 12:06. |
| | | Marko Adams kick attempt good. |
| | | DePauw University 7, Allegheny College 0 |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 38 yards, TOP 00:42 |
| | | Marko Adams kickoff 65 yards to the ALL0, touchback. |
| All | 1-10 | at All25 | ALLEGHENY COLLEGE drive start at 12:04. |
| All | 1-10 | at All25 | Tyler Balla rush for loss of 1 yard to the ALL24 (Will Longthorne). |
| All | 2-11 | at All24 | Logan Lee pass complete to Alex Victor for 1 yard to the ALL25 (Pete Nelson). |
| All | 3-10 | at All25 | Logan Lee rush for 5 yards to the ALL30 (Will Longthorne). |
| All | 4-5 | at All30 | McLaughlin punt 28 yards to the DPU42, Jason Kirchhoff return 0 yards to the DPU42 (Juwan Campbell). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 5 yards, TOP 01:59 |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu42 | DEPAUW UNIVERSITY drive start at 10:05. |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu42 | Matt Hunt pass complete to Brandon Lugar for 15 yards to the ALL43, 1ST DOWN DPU, out-of-bounds (David Perez). |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at All43 | Jason Kirchhoff rush for 9 yards to the ALL34 (Travis Thomas). |
| Dpu | 2-1 | at All34 | Matt Hunt pass incomplete to Andy Hunt (Davenport). |
| Dpu | 3-1 | at All34 | Jason Kirchhoff rush for 2 yards to the ALL32, 1ST DOWN DPU (Davenport). |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at All32 | Jason Kirchhoff rush for 8 yards to the ALL24 (Tristan Rhoades). |
| Dpu | 2-2 | at All24 | Jason Kirchhoff rush for 17 yards to the ALL7, 1ST DOWN DPU (Tristan Rhoades). |
| Dpu | 1-G | at All07 | Jason Kirchhoff rush for 2 yards to the ALL5 (Colten Buzard). |
| Dpu | 2-G | at All05 | Matt Hunt pass complete to Chase Sadler for 5 yards to the ALL0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 07:45. |
| | | Marko Adams kick attempt good. |
| | | DePauw University 14, Allegheny College 0 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 58 yards, TOP 02:27 |
| | | Marko Adams kickoff 65 yards to the ALL0, Jake Wilson return 22 yards to the ALL22 (Bren. Connelly). |
| All | 1-10 | at All22 | ALLEGHENY COLLEGE drive start at 07:38. |
| All | 1-10 | at All22 | Logan Lee pass complete to Alex Victor for 6 yards to the ALL28 (David Cory). |
| All | 2-4 | at All28 | Logan Lee rush for 7 yards to the ALL35, 1ST DOWN ALL (David Cory). |
| All | 1-10 | at All35 | Logan Lee pass incomplete to Alex Victor, dropped pass. |
| All | 2-10 | at All35 | Logan Lee pass incomplete to Alex Victor. |
| All | 3-10 | at All35 | Logan Lee pass incomplete to Alec Hutchin. |
| All | 4-10 | at All35 | McLaughlin punt 23 yards to the DPU42, fair catch by Jason Kirchhoff. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 13 yards, TOP 01:27 |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu42 | DEPAUW UNIVERSITY drive start at 06:11. |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu42 | Matt Hunt pass complete to Jason Kirchhoff for 7 yards to the DPU49 (Craye Nehler). |
| Dpu | 2-3 | at Dpu49 | Matt Hunt pass complete to Ian Good for 11 yards to the ALL40, 1ST DOWN DPU (David Perez). |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at All40 | Nick Delgado rush for 12 yards to the ALL28, 1ST DOWN DPU (Tristan Rhoades). |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at All28 | Matt Hunt pass complete to Chase Sadler for 28 yards to the ALL0, 1ST DOWN DPU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 05:13. |
| | | Marko Adams kick attempt good. |
| | | DePauw University 21, Allegheny College 0 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 58 yards, TOP 01:04 |
| | | Marko Adams kickoff 64 yards to the ALL1, Jake Wilson return 22 yards to the ALL23 (Bren. Connelly;Collin Cassady). |
| All | 1-10 | at All23 | ALLEGHENY COLLEGE drive start at 05:07. |
| All | 1-10 | at All23 | Tyler Balla rush for no gain to the ALL23 (Pete Nelson). |
| All | 2-10 | at All23 | Brandon Sellers rush for 3 yards to the ALL26 (Matt Mitsch). |
| All | 3-7 | at All26 | Logan Lee pass complete to Alex Victor for 74 yards to the DPU0, 1ST DOWN ALL, TOUCHDOWN, clock 03:48. |
| | | Ben Ziolkowski kick attempt good. |
| | | DePauw University 21, Allegheny College 7 |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 77 yards, TOP 01:25 |
| | | Ben Ziolkowski kickoff 54 yards to the DPU11, Jack Roberts return 27 yards to the DPU38 (Justin McClain). |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu38 | DEPAUW UNIVERSITY drive start at 03:42. |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu38 | Jason Kirchhoff rush for 62 yards to the ALL0, 1ST DOWN DPU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 03:31. |
| | | Marko Adams kick attempt good. |
| | | DePauw University 28, Allegheny College 7 |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 62 yards, TOP 00:16 |
| | | Marko Adams kickoff 65 yards to the ALL0, Jake Wilson return 21 yards to the ALL21, out-of-bounds (Cody Baker;Bren. Connelly). |
| All | 1-10 | at All21 | ALLEGHENY COLLEGE drive start at 03:26. |
| All | 1-10 | at All21 | Logan Lee pass complete to Alex Victor for 41 yards to the DPU38, 1ST DOWN ALL (Pete Nelson). |
| All | 1-10 | at Dpu38 | Logan Lee rush for 1 yard to the DPU37 (Thomas Gray). |
| All | 2-9 | at Dpu37 | Brandon Sellers rush for 3 yards to the DPU34 (Will Longthorne). |
| All | 3-6 | at Dpu34 | Logan Lee pass incomplete to John McFarland. |
| All | 4-6 | at Dpu34 | Timeout DePauw University, clock 01:25. |
| All | 4-6 | at Dpu34 | Logan Lee pass complete to John McFarland for 5 yards to the DPU29 (Joel Kauth). |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 50 yards, TOP 02:08 |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu29 | DEPAUW UNIVERSITY drive start at 01:18. |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu29 | Jason Kirchhoff rush for 41 yards to the ALL30, fumble forced by Travis Thomas, fumble by Jason Kirchhoff recovered by DPU Ben Wilson at ALL21, 1ST DOWN DPU. |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at All21 | Nick Delgado rush for 4 yards to the ALL17 (Jon Scroxton). |
| Dpu | 2-6 | at All17 | Nick Delgado rush for 17 yards to the ALL0, 1ST DOWN DPU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:33. |
| | | Marko Adams kick attempt good. |
| | | DePauw University 35, Allegheny College 7 |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 71 yards, TOP 00:58 |
| | | Marko Adams kickoff 62 yards to the ALL3, Jake Wilson return 19 yards to the ALL22, fumble forced by Bren. Connelly, fumble by Jake Wilson recovered by ALL Wesley Germain at ALL22. |
| All | 1-10 | at All22 | ALLEGHENY COLLEGE drive start at 00:20. |
| All | 1-10 | at All22 | Logan Lee sacked for loss of 8 yards to the ALL14 (Nate Orrison). |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 8 yards, TOP 02:57 |
| | | DePauw University 35, Allegheny College 7 |
| All | 2-18 | at All14 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| All | 2-18 | at All14 | Logan Lee rush for no gain to the ALL14 (Thomas Gray). |
| All | 3-18 | at All14 | Logan Lee pass complete to Tyler Balla for 5 yards to the ALL19 (Thomas Gray). |
| All | 4-13 | at All19 | McLaughlin punt 36 yards to the DPU45, fair catch by Jason Kirchhoff. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 3 yards, TOP 02:57 |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu45 | DEPAUW UNIVERSITY drive start at 12:23. |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu45 | Nick Delgado rush for 8 yards to the ALL47 (Davenport). |
| Dpu | 2-2 | at All47 | Nick Delgado rush for 43 yards to the ALL4, 1ST DOWN DPU (Aryn Wrona). |
| Dpu | 1-G | at All04 | Ramon Lopez rush for 2 yards to the ALL2 (Travis Thomas). |
| Dpu | 2-G | at All02 | Ramon Lopez rush for 2 yards to the ALL0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 11:23. |
| | | Marko Adams kick attempt good. |
| | | DePauw University 42, Allegheny College 7 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 55 yards, TOP 01:04 |
| | | Marko Adams kickoff 61 yards to the ALL4, Jake Wilson return 10 yards to the ALL14 (Jack Roberts). |
| All | 1-10 | at All14 | ALLEGHENY COLLEGE drive start at 11:19. |
| All | 1-10 | at All14 | Logan Lee pass complete to Alex Victor for 86 yards to the DPU0, 1ST DOWN ALL, TOUCHDOWN, clock 11:05. |
| | | Ben Ziolkowski kick attempt good. |
| | | DePauw University 42, Allegheny College 14 |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 86 yards, TOP 00:20 |
| | | Ben Ziolkowski kickoff 57 yards to the DPU8, Jack Roberts return 34 yards to the DPU42, out-of-bounds (Juwan Campbell). |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu42 | DEPAUW UNIVERSITY drive start at 10:59. |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu42 | Matt Hunt pass incomplete to Chase Sadler, PENALTY ALL pass interference (Aryn Wrona) 15 yards to the ALL43, 1ST DOWN DPU, NO PLAY. |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at All43 | Matt Hunt pass complete to Ian Good for loss of 2 yards to the ALL45 (Aryn Wrona). |
| Dpu | 2-12 | at All45 | Matt Hunt rush for 27 yards to the ALL18, 1ST DOWN DPU (Deangelo Logan). |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at All18 | Ramon Lopez rush for 3 yards to the ALL15 (Freddy Ruiz;Tristan Rhoades). |
| Dpu | 2-7 | at All15 | Ramon Lopez rush for loss of 2 yards to the ALL17 (Jahnaaman Boone). |
| Dpu | 3-9 | at All17 | Matt Hunt pass complete to Chase Sadler for 17 yards to the ALL0, 1ST DOWN DPU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 08:30. |
| | | Marko Adams kick attempt failed. |
| | | DePauw University 48, Allegheny College 14 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 58 yards, TOP 02:34 |
| | | Marko Adams kickoff 63 yards to the ALL2, Jake Wilson return 44 yards to the ALL46 (Ryan Price). |
| All | 1-10 | at All46 | ALLEGHENY COLLEGE drive start at 08:25. |
| All | 1-10 | at All46 | Logan Lee pass complete to John McFarland for 15 yards to the DPU39, 1ST DOWN ALL. |
| All | 1-10 | at Dpu39 | Logan Lee pass incomplete to Alec Hutchin. |
| All | 2-10 | at Dpu39 | Logan Lee pass complete to John McFarland for 12 yards to the DPU27, 1ST DOWN ALL (Zachary Reichle;Brooks Hepp). |
| All | 1-10 | at Dpu27 | Logan Lee pass incomplete to Alec Hutchin (David Cory). |
| All | 2-10 | at Dpu27 | Logan Lee pass complete to John McFarland for 24 yards to the DPU3, 1ST DOWN ALL (Rocky Leffler;Zachary Reichle). |
| All | 1-G | at Dpu03 | Logan Lee rush for loss of 1 yard to the DPU4 (Nate Orrison;David Cory). |
| All | 2-G | at Dpu04 | Logan Lee pass incomplete to Alex Victor. |
| All | 3-G | at Dpu04 | Logan Lee pass intercepted by Will Longthorne at the DPU10, Will Longthorne return 0 yards to the DPU10 (Pete Nelson). |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 50 yards, TOP 03:50 |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu10 | DEPAUW UNIVERSITY drive start at 04:35. |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu10 | Ramon Lopez rush for no gain to the DPU10 (Travis Thomas). |
| Dpu | 2-10 | at Dpu10 | Ramon Lopez rush for 7 yards to the DPU17 (Tristan Rhoades;Freddy Ruiz). |
| Dpu | 3-3 | at Dpu17 | Timeout Allegheny College, clock 03:13. |
| Dpu | 3-3 | at Dpu17 | Matt Hunt pass incomplete to Ryan Grizzard (Craye Nehler). |
| Dpu | 4-3 | at Dpu17 | Conn. Patterson punt 36 yards to the ALL47, fair catch by Jake Wilson. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 7 yards, TOP 01:31 |
| All | 1-10 | at All47 | ALLEGHENY COLLEGE drive start at 03:04. |
| All | 1-10 | at All47 | PENALTY DPU encroachment 5 yards to the DPU48. |
| All | 1-5 | at Dpu48 | Logan Lee pass complete to Alex Victor for 1 yard to the DPU47 (Cody Baker). |
| All | 2-4 | at Dpu47 | Logan Lee pass incomplete to Ben Bachik. |
| All | 3-4 | at Dpu47 | Logan Lee pass intercepted by Will Longthorne at the DPU41, Will Longthorne return 0 yards to the DPU41. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 6 yards, TOP 00:52 |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu41 | DEPAUW UNIVERSITY drive start at 02:12. |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu41 | Ramon Lopez rush for 2 yards to the DPU43 (Davenport). |
| | | Injury timeout. |
| Dpu | 2-8 | at Dpu43 | Matt Hunt sacked for loss of 10 yards to the DPU33 (Davenport), PENALTY ALL personal foul (Davenport) 15 yards to the DPU48, 1ST DOWN DPU. |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu48 | 1st and 10. |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu48 | Ramon Lopez rush for 1 yard to the DPU49 (Davenport). |
| Dpu | 2-9 | at Dpu49 | Ramon Lopez rush for 3 yards to the ALL48 (Jahnaaman Boone). |
| Dpu | 3-6 | at All48 | Matt Hunt pass complete to Steve Kubiak for 1 yard to the ALL47 (Freddy Ruiz). |
| Dpu | 4-5 | at All47 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 12 yards, TOP 02:12 |
| | | DePauw University 48, Allegheny College 14 |
| Dpu | 4-5 | at All47 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, ALL ball on ALL35. |
| | | DePauw receives, Allegheny defends north goal. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 12 yards, TOP 02:12 |
| | | Ben Ziolkowski kickoff 55 yards to the DPU10, Zac Fouche return 13 yards to the DPU23 (Jake Wilson). |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu23 | DEPAUW UNIVERSITY drive start at 14:55. |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu23 | Jason Kirchhoff rush for 1 yard to the DPU24 (Jon Scroxton). |
| Dpu | 2-9 | at Dpu24 | Matt Hunt pass complete to Chase Sadler for 76 yards to the ALL0, 1ST DOWN DPU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 14:01. |
| | | Marko Adams kick attempt good. |
| | | DePauw University 55, Allegheny College 14 |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 77 yards, TOP 00:55 |
| | | Marko Adams kickoff 65 yards to the ALL0, touchback. |
| All | 1-10 | at All25 | ALLEGHENY COLLEGE drive start at 14:00. |
| All | 1-10 | at All25 | Logan Lee pass complete to Alex Victor for 10 yards to the ALL35, 1ST DOWN ALL, out-of-bounds (Pete Nelson). |
| All | 1-10 | at All35 | Tyler Balla rush for 2 yards to the ALL37 (Will Longthorne). |
| All | 2-8 | at All37 | Tyler Balla rush for loss of 1 yard to the ALL36 (Rocky Leffler). |
| All | 3-9 | at All36 | Logan Lee pass incomplete to John McFarland. |
| All | 4-9 | at All36 | McLaughlin punt 40 yards to the DPU24, downed. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 11 yards, TOP 01:50 |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu24 | DEPAUW UNIVERSITY drive start at 12:10. |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu24 | Ramon Lopez rush for 10 yards to the DPU34, 1ST DOWN DPU (Tristan Rhoades). |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu34 | Ramon Lopez rush for 1 yard to the DPU35 (Jon Scroxton). |
| Dpu | 2-9 | at Dpu35 | Jake Lasky rush for 8 yards to the DPU43 (Jon Scroxton). |
| Dpu | 3-1 | at Dpu43 | Ramon Lopez rush for 1 yard to the DPU44 (Deangelo Logan), PENALTY ALL encroachment (Deangelo Logan) 5 yards to the DPU48, 1ST DOWN DPU, NO PLAY. |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu48 | Ramon Lopez rush for 6 yards to the ALL46 (Matt Ledesma). |
| | | Injury timeout. |
| Dpu | 2-4 | at All46 | Clock 09:40. |
| Dpu | 2-4 | at All46 | Demarco Henry rush for 7 yards to the ALL39, 1ST DOWN DPU (Tristan Rhoades). |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at All39 | Ramon Lopez rush for 5 yards to the ALL34 (Tristan Rhoades). |
| Dpu | 2-5 | at All34 | Ramon Lopez rush for 4 yards to the ALL30 (Tristan Rhoades). |
| Dpu | 3-1 | at All30 | Ramon Lopez rush for 2 yards to the ALL28, 1ST DOWN DPU (Deangelo Logan). |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at All28 | Ramon Lopez rush for 1 yard to the ALL27 (Aeschbacher). |
| Dpu | 2-9 | at All27 | Jake Lasky rush for 27 yards to the ALL0, 1ST DOWN DPU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:20. |
| | | Marko Adams kick attempt good. |
| | | DePauw University 62, Allegheny College 14 |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 76 yards, TOP 05:56 |
| | | Marko Adams kickoff 65 yards to the ALL0, Jake Wilson return 20 yards to the ALL20 (Chase Sadler;Harry Bell). |
| All | 1-10 | at All20 | ALLEGHENY COLLEGE drive start at 06:14. |
| All | 1-10 | at All20 | Logan Lee pass intercepted by Brooks Hepp at the DPU35, Brooks Hepp return 0 yards to the DPU35 (Alex Victor). |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:07 |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu35 | DEPAUW UNIVERSITY drive start at 06:07. |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu35 | Demarco Henry rush for 2 yards to the DPU37 (Miles Oladimeji;Aeschbacher). |
| Dpu | 2-8 | at Dpu37 | Demarco Henry rush for 3 yards to the DPU40 (Juwan Campbell). |
| Dpu | 3-5 | at Dpu40 | Demarco Henry rush for 56 yards to the ALL4, 1ST DOWN DPU (Aryn Wrona). |
| Dpu | 1-G | at All04 | Demarco Henry rush for loss of 2 yards to the ALL6 (Miles Oladimeji). |
| Dpu | 2-G | at All06 | Jake Lasky rush for 6 yards to the ALL0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 03:16. |
| | | Marko Adams kick attempt good. |
| | | DePauw University 69, Allegheny College 14 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 65 yards, TOP 02:59 |
| | | Marko Adams kickoff 65 yards to the ALL0, Jake Wilson return 20 yards to the ALL20 (Bren. Connelly;Collin Cassady). |
| All | 1-10 | at All20 | ALLEGHENY COLLEGE drive start at 03:08. |
| All | 1-10 | at All20 | Alex Victor rush for 1 yard to the ALL21 (David Cory). |
| All | 2-9 | at All21 | Logan Lee pass incomplete, PENALTY ALL holding (Antinozzi) 10 yards to the ALL11, NO PLAY. |
| All | 2-19 | at All11 | Logan Lee pass complete to John McFarland for 8 yards to the ALL19 (Ryan Price). |
| All | 3-11 | at All19 | Logan Lee pass incomplete to Alex Victor. |
| All | 4-11 | at All19 | McLaughlin punt 32 yards to the DPU49, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 01:39 |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu49 | DEPAUW UNIVERSITY drive start at 01:29. |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu49 | JT Williams rush for 2 yards to the ALL49 (Corey Laskey). |
| Dpu | 2-8 | at All49 | JT Williams rush for 1 yard to the ALL48 (Aeschbacher). |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 3 yards, TOP 02:17 |
| | | DePauw University 69, Allegheny College 14 |
| Dpu | 3-7 | at All48 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Dpu | 3-7 | at All48 | JT Williams rush for 1 yard to the ALL47 (Miles Oladimeji). |
| Dpu | 4-6 | at All47 | Conn. Patterson punt 30 yards to the ALL17, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 4 yards, TOP 02:17 |
| All | 1-10 | at All17 | ALLEGHENY COLLEGE drive start at 14:12. |
| All | 1-10 | at All17 | Brandon Sellers rush for 4 yards to the ALL21 (Dominic Miranda). |
| All | 2-6 | at All21 | Jon Nigro pass complete to Jake Wilson for no gain to the ALL21, out-of-bounds (Ryan Price). |
| All | 3-6 | at All21 | Jon Nigro pass complete to Brandon Sellers for 5 yards to the ALL26 (Zach Williams). |
| All | 4-1 | at All26 | McLaughlin punt 47 yards to the DPU27, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 9 yards, TOP 02:07 |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu27 | DEPAUW UNIVERSITY drive start at 12:05. |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu27 | JT Williams rush for 3 yards to the DPU30 (McLaughlin). |
| Dpu | 2-7 | at Dpu30 | JT Williams rush for loss of 2 yards to the DPU28 (Zi'Tear Wilson). |
| Dpu | 3-9 | at Dpu28 | JT Williams rush for 4 yards to the DPU32 (Cole Morris), PENALTY DPU personal foul off-setting, PENALTY ALL personal foul off-setting. |
| Dpu | 4-5 | at Dpu32 | Conn. Patterson punt 43 yards to the ALL25, Jake Wilson return 9 yards to the ALL34 (Thomas Gray;Zachary Reichle), PENALTY ALL illegal block (Adrian Garcia) 10 yards to the ALL24, 1st and 10, ALL ball on ALL24. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 5 yards, TOP 02:23 |
| All | 1-10 | at All24 | ALLEGHENY COLLEGE drive start at 09:42. |
| All | 1-10 | at All24 | Brandon Sellers rush for 2 yards to the ALL26 (Collin Cassady). |
| All | 2-8 | at All26 | Jon Nigro pass incomplete (Matt Robinson). |
| All | 3-8 | at All26 | Jon Nigro pass complete to Thomas Jr. for 9 yards to the ALL35, 1ST DOWN ALL (Ryan Price). |
| All | 1-10 | at All35 | Jon Nigro rush for 2 yards to the ALL37 (Collin Cassady). |
| All | 2-8 | at All37 | Jon Nigro pass complete to Guzman for 63 yards to the DPU0, 1ST DOWN ALL, TOUCHDOWN, clock 07:29. |
| | | Ben Ziolkowski kick attempt good. |
| | | DePauw University 69, Allegheny College 21 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 76 yards, TOP 02:21 |
| | | Ben Ziolkowski kickoff 63 yards to the DPU2, Cade Jones return 20 yards to the DPU22 (Albert Kolubah;Nick Cervone). |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu22 | DEPAUW UNIVERSITY drive start at 07:21. |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu22 | Demarco Henry rush for no gain to the DPU22 (Aeschbacher;McLaughlin). |
| Dpu | 2-10 | at Dpu22 | Demarco Henry rush for 5 yards to the DPU27 (Corey Laskey;Ben Capella). |
| Dpu | 3-5 | at Dpu27 | Demarco Henry rush for 7 yards to the DPU34, 1ST DOWN DPU (Adrian Garcia). |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at Dpu34 | Demarco Henry rush for 3 yards to the DPU37 (Ben Capella;Miles Oladimeji). |
| Dpu | 2-7 | at Dpu37 | Demarco Henry rush for 1 yard to the DPU38 (Jon Scroxton). |
| Dpu | 3-6 | at Dpu38 | Matt Labus rush for 15 yards to the ALL47, 1ST DOWN DPU (Cole Morris). |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at All47 | Demarco Henry rush for 5 yards to the ALL42 (Juwan Campbell;Ben Capella). |
| Dpu | 2-5 | at All42 | Demarco Henry rush for 4 yards to the ALL38 (Corey Laskey;Juwan Campbell). |
| Dpu | 3-1 | at All38 | Demarco Henry rush for 3 yards to the ALL35, 1ST DOWN DPU (Juwan Campbell;Ben Capella). |
| Dpu | 1-10 | at All35 | Demarco Henry rush for 8 yards to the ALL27 (Miles Oladimeji;Dylan Ukasik). |
| Dpu | 2-2 | at All27 | Team rush for loss of 1 yard to the ALL28. |
| Dpu | 3-3 | at All28 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 50 yards, TOP 07:21 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | DePauw University 69, Allegheny College 21 |